拒絕理由：IAP商品在iphone、ipad版本互通

首先看蘋果reject原文

11.4 - Apps that use IAP to purchase credits or other currencies must consume those credits within the App
11.4 Details


We noticed that your app uses In-App Purchase products to purchase credits or currencies that are not consumed within the app, which is not allowed. 

Specifically, we found that your app shares the IAP credits with another app “xxx應用HD”.


Next Steps


Please revise your app to ensure that the credits or currencies purchased with In-App Purchase products are used within the app or remove the In-App Purchases entirely.

大意是，在同一款應用的iphone版本中購買商品，然後可以在iPad版本中使用，這不符合IAP的稽核規則。

解決方案

按照我的理解，同一款應用的iphone、iPad版本保持資料同步是符合使用者預期的，因此我選擇申訴。

申訴原文：
蘋果內購商品是在itunesconnect後臺建立的，根據蘋果後臺要求，每個商品都是唯一獨立的，且無法在不同應用之間共用，我們不可能對商品進行共用。對於同一個遊戲的iPhone版和ipad版來說，保持商品的價格、描述一致，是符合玩家的預期的，難道作為一個玩家，你希望同一款遊戲的iPhone版和ipad版必須完全不同嗎？
請重新稽核應用，慎重考慮我們的意見，謝謝

Apple purchased goods within a background in itunesconnect established, according to Apple backstage requirements, each commodity is the only independent, and can not be shared between different applications, we can not be a common commodity. For the same game for the iPhone version and ipad version, keeping commodity prices, description consistent, is in line with the expectations of the players, do not as a player, you want a game with the iPhone version and ipad version must be completely different from it?
Please re-examine the application, carefully consider our advice, thank you

蘋果再次稽核

需要說明一點，對於我的申訴理由，其實要看蘋果稽核人員的理（xin）解（qing），因為我在試圖混淆概念。reject的理由是IAP購買後的商品互通，而我解釋的是IAP展示的內容相同。
本案例中，稽核人員認為IAP商品的互通是可以理解和接受的。

蘋果回覆原文

June 25, 2015 at 6:14 AM
From Apple
11.4 - Apps that use IAP to purchase credits or other currencies must consume those credits within the App
Hello,

Please disregard the previous message. We apologize for the confusion.

We will continue to review the app and will notify you if we found more issues.

Best Regards

App Store Review

June 25, 2015 at 4:23 AM
From Apple
Hello,

Thank you for your response. When we used the demo account to make purchase in xxx應用, and then we logged in to xxx應用HD, we found the account balance of xxx應用HD reflected the amount we purchased in xxx應用.

Best Regards